RAS reiterates call for publication of cuts evidence

The Royal Astronomical Society (RAS) is once again demanding that a report used to inform damaging cuts to astronomy and space science be made public.

It follows a meeting of the House of Commons Science and Technology Select Committee yesterday (Tuesday) that saw leading astronomers and physicists highlight the challenges facing the UK's Particle Physics, Astronomy and Nuclear Physics (PPAN) community in the wake of funding withdrawals.

The RAS remains deeply concerned by the gulf between the headline funding figures from UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) and what researchers are experiencing on the ground, with cuts of around a third across astronomy research projects.

A commitment to protect fundamental science must be judged by what researchers can actually deliver, not simply by how funding is categorised or presented.

Professor Catherine Heymans, the Astronomer Royal for Scotland, Professor Jon Butterworth, Dr Simon Williams and Professor George Efstathiou all gave compelling evidence as the Committee scrutinised cuts to funding announced by the Science and Technology Facilities Council (STFC) earlier this year.

This included fears about the impact on major research facilities, a potential "brain drain" and knock-on effects for universities and business.

Committee MPs also examined the transparency of the decisions made and whether STFC's prioritisation process had been clearly communicated to the scientific community. "The outcomes are there, but the rationale is not actually public," said Professor Butterworth.

Following the meeting, RAS President Professor Jim Wild said: "Yesterday's evidence reinforced why we are renewing our call for UKRI to publish the STFC Science Board's prioritisation report in full. 

"The scientific community has been told the decisions, but has still not seen the independent scientific recommendations presented to the STFC executive, or how those recommendations informed the final outcomes.

"Decisions of this magnitude, affecting internationally important research programmes and the careers of scientists across the UK, demand transparency and accountability. Without that openness, it is difficult to see how confidence and trust in the process can be restored."

The Committee Chair Chi Onwurah also highlighted a crucial distinction during the session: protecting quality-related funding for universities is not the same as protecting curiosity-driven research. Both are important, but they are not interchangeable.

The RAS wishes to thank Professor Heymans, Professor Butterworth, Dr Williams and Professor Efstathiou for their evidence, as well as the Committee MPs for scrutinising decisions that will have a long-lasting and potentially devastating impact on the UK's scientific research community.

Submitted by Sam Tonkin on